Current Events

Disturbing Police Strip Search Gone Bad

By Citizen Correspondent Michelle Kenneth
Date Posted: 02/05/08
Reader Rating: rating

I usually don't repost something like this, but it was so disturbing, the world needs to know about this. It's shocking that the news station in Ohio heard nothing about it until someone sent them a video. Click here for more information.

Stark County, Ohio police are under investigation over the use of excessive force for strip-searching Hope Steffey. Yet, this is not the only case in recent months of what is being deemed as an illegal strip-search.

The department is also facing accusations by three young teenage girls ages 14, 15 and 16 that say that they too were illegally strip-searched on May 18, 2007 for what the officers deemed as being for "their own safety." (For further information:In Depth Coverage of the Incident)

But let's not stop there. A Stark County police officer is also up for capital murder after he strangled his pregnant girlfriend to death, rolled her body up in a rug, and then dumped her body some twenty miles away. (For further information:Police Officer Murders Pregnant Girlfriend )

Could this be an out of control police department?

***
For more on this story, read The Degradation Of A Strip Search












Tags:

Comments

Re: Disturbing Police Strip Search Gone Bad

By Sara-Jane, May 31, 2008 at 06:18

We have not been able to find the latest news on the Hope Steffey forced strip and Cavity Search by the Stark County Jail Officers.

It was noted that the Ohio stae DA's office would make a Judicial Review in May but this has not been published at least not in the UK.

This is a most important case for liberty in general and for the credibility of the USA in particular following on from the stories of abuse in Iraq.

Is it possible to obtain the latest news in this case

Thank you

Re: Disturbing Police Strip Search Gone Bad

By Heather Wallace, June 1, 2008 at 08:54

Hi Sara-Jane - I've been in touch with the lawyers, requesting an interview. She has declined interviews, but I will see if I can get an update on Monday for you...

Heather Wallace
senior editor
Orato.com

Re: Disturbing Police Strip Search Gone Bad

By Michelle Kenneth, May 31, 2008 at 07:15

I emailed answers to the questions you were posing the other day.

The Ohio State Attorney General's Office has not released their findings. There's been some controversy surrounding this case inside the AG's office, along with the AG himself. The AG himself is currently under investigation.

Re: Disturbing Police Strip Search Gone Bad

By Sara-Jane, June 1, 2008 at 08:27

Thank you for reply via blog but I have not received E mail response.

I would be grateful if you would resend as myself and others have shown great interest in this case as trainee solicitors in the UK

Re: Disturbing Police Strip Search Gone Bad

By Bud Oracle (not verified), April 28, 2008 at 09:52

A "Stark" look at what, I, through multiple illegal, personal, contacts myself with the police, know to be the facts of what is happening in Canadian Policing everywhere.

Ian Bush was hauled in to a RCMP detachment for an open beer at a hockey game, and as the video cameras-failed to record the events, ended up with a single bullet hole in the back of the head.

I personally gathered and still have in my possession over 600 signatures in downtown Vancouver last year. It was a demonstration for the cause of more police accountability by ringing a school bell and shouting "This bell tolls for Ian Bush, Shot in the back of the head by the RCMP"

And we have few functioning cameras anywhere, unlike the states where the cops ignor the cameras to begin with..

Until our police and leaders set an example by being law abiding, are held accountable under the laws, there will be no respect for the law. Only a drive for better weaponry will occur,.a ruthless race for violent supremacy will /is overtaking our criminals. We've had 30 murders in the first 3 months of 2008.

Something is very wrong with King John's men. Where is Robin Hood?

Re: Disturbing Police Strip Search Gone Bad

By ronbeal, March 15, 2008 at 21:43

I live in the UK and quite frankly viewing this clip has sent shivers down my spine. I find it hard to believe this was actually genuine police Officers conducting this ???? I’m not really quite sure how one would exactly describe what happened in that cell. I must admit at first glance it could easily have been confused as a small group of people enthusiastically filming some cheap porno movie. I’ve been trying to piece together what really would have been their motivation for stripping this poor woman completely stark naked. Surely one could only accept such actions being justifiably ‘for her own protection, had they in fact let her keep her lower underwear on, leaving her with perhaps a small amount of dignity, and quite frankly male officers being present in the cell at the time was bad enough but actually taking part in this strip, would only force peoples imaginations to run completely wild. The whole complexity of this incident is hard to understand, surely they had to be aware their actions were being filmed. I also fail to understand how the Sheriff is genuinely able to justify their actions. Once the lawsuit gets into full swing this particular scandal could escalate and cause disastrous consequences for the Police Dept’s relations with the general public, but having said that, it so happens these days that every now and again when the public is protesting over some police issues or the like, very often the general contention is that these things so very simply get brushed under the carpet so to speak and we never get to hear any more about them. I’ve read some other comments on this site suggesting sexual motivation, but to me it doesn’t seem very likely because of the sheer number of male and female officers involved at the time. With respect, may I say, to holiday in beautiful America has always been very high on my agenda, but please forgive me now when I say that, should this particular Police Dept get away with their treatment of this poor innocent woman, then to be quite honest, it’s fair to say that frankly I’d worry less if my family holidays ended up elsewhere, perhaps a place where Police Officers behave a little more dignified and just a little more peaceful. I apologise if anyone’s offended by any of my comments but I feel these words need to be said, and I’m sorry this piece is so long it probably comes across more like an article than just my comments. Finally in conclusion, I am of course fully aware that in general the Police are a decent bunch and do one heck of a job, putting their lives at risk every day and so on, and naturally I’m sure no one would argue that they are a courageous lot and it’s quite unjust and unfair that this will have to reflect on so many. But clearly this really is scary stuff, no matter what the outcome, it’s still going to continue to be a worry and concern for a whole lot of people.
Ron Beal
UK

Re: Disturbing Police Strip Search Gone Bad

By Melkor, February 11, 2008 at 12:11

I would like to add that I think Brandon is right on the money. Those involved should do the right thing and end it - for them, there is no redmption in this life, better to start anew in the next.

Is there anyone still out there that does not think this sort of thing goes on in EVERY police department on this continent?

Shame on the police - N.W.A. had it right.

Re: Disturbing Police Strip Search Gone Bad

By Trisha Baptie, February 9, 2008 at 12:01

I watched this video the day it was posted and it has taken me until now to respond because I could not put a proper descriptive word to how I felt until now.
I think the word is apathetic.
I was truly surprised to see the outrage ( although I thought Brandon's went over the top) at how this women was treated, which was absolutely deplorable don't get me wrong but I couldn't understand how people were under the impression that this does not happen all the time.
Let me make myself clear here for starters i think the police have a hard job and for the most part they do an amazing job, we ask so much for them and return so little to them, they have a thankless job for the most part, yet who amongst us wouldn't call 911 if we feared for our safety.

Back to the clip, I have seen girls like this one in cells, failing about screaming almost incoherent, were they high? Mentally unstable? A harm to themselves? Others?
Who knows but we ask the police to deal with them and because of what they see daily they have no reason to believe anyone until the person is confined and both parties safety is assured.
If there is one thing I know about dealing with the cops is the best thing is just let them cuff you if that's what they are going to do and try talking to them once the situation is diffused.
Am I saying what the officers did is right NO, they should face a punishment committee and be rightly punished and there should be changes to police techniques, but with the situations they walk in on, how do they know what is the truth and what isn't?

But it is a lot easier to judge from the safety of our computer chair.

I do know this kind of thing goes on right here in BC from personal experience, there used to be a bar on Hastings called the Sunrise and a little store beside it called the Sports Cafe. Most people who hung out there has something or another do do with the drug trade, so when the cops came in they would gather up the girls who they suspected of packing (carrying drugs) for their boyfriends or someone they worked for and took us into the back.
There was this little bathroom and we would one at a time go in there with a officer and take off our shirt and lift up the bottom of our bra's so the coke balls would fall out if they were there and separate our breasts to show them we had none in our cleavage.
We took off our shoes, they went through the pockets of our pants and as time went on we had to start pulling down our pants underwear and all, to show we had no dope there.
We both knew they were not allowed to do this, they didn't want the paperwork of taking us in and we knew we had no recourse.
Yet surprisingly over time instead of becoming more angry about what they did I personally became more grateful because after a while there was finally a woman paired with the guy who did this so it was now at least there was a girl doing the searches. (FYI~ I never did have dope on me, my man wrapped it in plastic and kept it in his beer bottle)
To have that done to oneself just entrenches the belief of us and them and makes it even harder to look at the chasm that separates you and the rest of the world and think that you can ever over come it.

I was just at a meeting yesterday with a organization who works with young women in the correction system and the women who ran it was talking about how they found out the girls ( in youth custody) were being given breast exams as part of a forensic psychological review by a male doctor and when they questioned the powers that be about why they were getting breast exams during a psych exam they were kicked out of the facility and are now having to fight to get back in.
Trust me it happens, but what is a woman supposed to do in that position when all the people she can go to are men who could never see her perspective or who silence her by sticking to the “boys club” rules.
Ultimately I think it shows how much further we have to go in women's equality.

Re: Disturbing Police Strip Search Gone Bad

By Hazel8500, March 8, 2008 at 08:30

What bothers me the most re this footage is A) Stepha Hope was the victim and the 911 call was made on her behalf. B) If this was due to a boys club mentality, how do we explain the female officers participation in Mrs. Hope's brutalization? And C) Mrs. Hope was not high, drunk or otherwise out of control or displaying potential for herself harm or harm to others. She simply made a mistake and gave her deceased sisters drivers license to the arriving officer. It was when she realized she gave the wrong ID (she kept her sisters card as a momento, afterall it had her picture on it) and asked for it back that the mayhem got swinging. It appears that her request for the return of her item marked her in the eyes of the cops as being resistant and once a cop thinks you are resisting their authoritahhh you are in danger of being tasered, cuffed, dragged, slammed, and strip searched or worse.

Someone mentioned in the comments if you're in danger who do you call? 911. Well I have in the past on more than one occasion. I now know I'd have second thoughts if the occassion arose today to call 911. not because of this footage, but because of my own experiences of being victimized, calling the cops going through all the red tape and emotional turmoil of reliving the experience only to be told time and time again - nothing can be done. The next time I get robbed, rolled, beaten or worse, I can not say for sure that I'd call the cops. I mean why bother?

Re: Disturbing Police Strip Search Gone Bad

By Brandon, February 9, 2008 at 14:44

I wanted to add, with the advantage of sober second thought, that I completely stand by what I wrote earlier.

If honour still exists, if shame still exists, then the only way for the men involved in this to endure is in a permanent shame. Look at the shame they've brought their profession, their city, county and state. Imagine the shame they've cast upon their wives and children. Shame like this has only one redemption - an honourable death. We do not speak ill of the dead because death wipes the karma clean. In my moral universe the only way for one to live is honourably - and the only choice left to those involved in this act is to honourably withdraw from life.

I know that this is not the organizing principle of our society. Life is more precious to us than justice and honour. Life over love, over reason. Life over everything. We preserve the lives of monsters and let justice wallow in disrepair. Consider the creatures we preserve in prisons who have taken so many lives. Life dominates the modern morality - and honour is all but forgotten.

This is precisely why these transgressions will continue in perpetuity - because society is bereft of any real morality now. Life is more important than morality. And as long as that is the case, there is no chance of ending these tragedies. Only once morality and honour are paramount to life, can there be a change in the behaviour of men.

So to those involved in this act or any like it, I repeat - fall on your swords.

Re: Disturbing Police Strip Search Gone Bad

By Michelle Kenneth, February 9, 2008 at 13:20

Your last sentence summed it all up completely.

Do you think perhaps you've been de-sensitized to strip searches?

What makes the Stark County case different is the unfortunate fact that a "VICTIM" was put through this. While it was unfortunate that the cop mistook her for the aggressor, there's the whole matter that took place when she reached the local jail. She had a chipped tooth from being thrown against the hood of the car; when she asked a question in response if she was an endangerment to herself, she was dropped and without explaining what was going on, she was being strip searched.

The part that sickens me is the part when her underwear was being taken off of her. What's going on through most people's minds is the: "Oh my, I think they're going to rape her." It is that moment you realize what was EXACTLY going through her mind. She had no idea why all of these officers were taking her clothes off. She had not been formally charged, yet.

Hope Steffey was not on any substance. She was clean.

There is also the case of the three teenage girls who were deemed to be an endangerment to themselves on a trespassing charge. This takes on a new role, b/c "CHILD ABUSE" could be cited here. Why were there parents not contacted at this point? A parent/guardian should have been present to protect the rights of the child. No parent/guardian was called in this instance.

Also, a police officer is not a licensed psychologist or doctor. How can a police officer determine that someone is an endangerment to themselves in a confined cell with handcuffs (and no prior convictions)? When I worked w/ the police department, all shoelaces, belts, etc. were removed. They got to keep their clothes on. There were cameras for each cell which was monitored before they went to central lock-up. In central lock-up, they are given a prison uniform to wear. They are not forced to sit in their cells for 6 hours with no clothes or a blanket to cover themselves in the dead of winter (those cells are incredibly cold). That becomes INHUMANE.

In cases of those individuals on substances, they are either taken to the drunk tank (not located at the precinct) or a hospital facility to de-tox. A police officer does not determine in the local jail whether someone is an endangerment to themselves. The protocol for the nation's capitol is to remove all objects that a person could hang themselves with. There are no strip searches. Pat downs can reveal drugs and we can ask them to remove all drugs from their persons, or we will remove them. Most times, those in the interview rooms remove all drugs from their persons.

If a "strip search" were to take place, at the least, their underwear is on and it is monitored. Police officers are always held accountable for their actions. That's what internal affairs are for in the cities.

Also, Stark County's policy is that only same sex strip searches can take place. Stark County officers violated their own policies, which means that several officers are in trouble.

Hope Steffey can also sue the department for duress and psychological trauma. Her criminal charges are going to be thrown out completely b/c the officer blundered and arrested the victim...and of course, what you see in this video is enough to throw her entire criminal case out.

I'm sure this stuff does happen more than we've heard about in the past, but these things need to be put to a stop. Perhaps a complete overhaul on how we are policed is needed, so that it doesn't violate our civil or human rights.

Re: Disturbing Police Strip Search Gone Bad

By Trisha Baptie, February 9, 2008 at 16:18

If the police are not trained Doctor's or psychologist's, how then are they to know what is wrong with the person they are dealing with and how to properly deal with them?
We do ask a lot of our police and give them very little training and put them in very frightening circumstances.
While I do passionately agree that our agree that civil and human rights must be protected, how do we then in turn protect the police in what we ask them to do and the situations we ask them to put themselves in to protect us?
I will be the first to admit I have attacked police in 2 diffrent situations, violently .
So how do we teach police how to deal with the innocent like the woman in the video while still protecting themselves and the public from people like I was 10 years ago?
OK, i am not defending the police in this video , but I think there is a bigger picture to deal with as well.
I look at the police as a very deep rooted "boy's club" mentality that is still very behind in their thinking towards women, youth and things like sexual assault, domestic violence and issues like that, however I do see them making slow changes toward changing that thinking.
Vancouver's police has come out and said that they would never support a brothel because they see it for what it is, slavery and violence towards women.
Yet while we are asking these people in one breath be compassionate and supportive in hard circumstance we are also saying when dealing with a drunk with a knife in public take him down by all means necessary to secure public safety.
We expect them to be many things cold and indifferent when their lives are at risk to access a situation and loving and compassionate while dealing with other circumstances.
It is a hard job.
What was captured in this video is wrong no two ways about it.
The officers should have to answer for their actions and steps must be put in place to ensure they never happen again, absolutly.
It was a violation of her, but there is a very big picture to look at here.
In Vancouver and surrouning area as far as I know most of our drunk tanks are in fact in the police departments building in the city cells . We have re-man's where you go if you are charged with something but you don't go there just 'casue your drunk you usually ride it out in city cells. I have not been in the drunk tank in 11 years or so, so it could have also changed.

Re: Disturbing Police Strip Search Gone Bad

By Michelle Kenneth, February 10, 2008 at 07:36

To answer your first question, police are trained to know when someone is on a substance and how to approach the matter. They are trained on how to identify the symptoms of drug/alcohol use. No one had a weapon in either cases. When a weapon is involved, that is a different element we are introducing into the equation and things are treated differently.

In the two videos, the main items that police are citing to perform strip searches are "endangerment" and "terrorism." What happens on the street is quite different than what happens in a confined, controlled environment where the security personnel are in complete control. I think in all of your examples, you keep going back to what is going on in the streets. Just focusing on the case at hand, it is completely different b/c it did not occur on the street, but inside the jail. The "endangerment" decisions were not made out on the streets in the Stark County cases, they were made inside the station while the person was handcuffed and in the confines of the jail. Not one single individual that was cited was on a substance.

My examples on how police officers in Washington, DC deal with "endangerment" dealt with inside a police station and not out on the streets.

What happens out on the streets are completely different, because as some officers will say: the streets are controlled by the populace. How they police on the streets is completely different and they react according to the situation at hand.

This whole case deals with what happened once they entered into the police's controlled environment. They are not licensed doctor's or psychologists, so how are they to determine that someone is an endangerment to themselves? They must treat every person taken into custody the same way. Remove any objects they could use to harm themselves. Monitor the cells with use of cameras. When each person walks in, you assume they could possibly endanger themselves, so you go through the motions of removing any and all possible objects that they could use as a weapon on themselves or on others.

You don't leave them in a cell naked for 6 hours. Usually when cops do stuff like that, it's ill will. That was not their protocol. They were trying to teach her a lesson.

Re: Disturbing Police Strip Search Gone Bad

By benali, February 8, 2008 at 22:38

In the city of Chicago, Illinois, women were regularly strip-searched for ROUTINE TRAFFIC VIOLATIONS from the 1950s until the late 1970s. Hundreds of thousands of women were subjected to this abuse over three decades.

Women who did not comply voluntarily were brutally and violently stripped by police. Situations as minor as excessive speed or missing a stop sign often spiralled into this tragedy.

This scandal was exposed in the early 1980s in various Chicago newspapers and on TV. (I wanted to provide a good link describing this, but since it all occurred pre-internet, the best I could do was to find court filings from the era that verify it (eg: http://www.altlaw.org/v1/cases/489181 and http://www.peopleslawoffice.com/cases/victories/).)

My personal belief is that most US police officers work very hard and risk their lives in performance of a critical public service. Unfortunately, in various jurisdictions at various times, the policing power has been systematically abused. I have lived in small towns in the south where the American principle of "local control of police" means unchecked corruption or abuse of police power. What we need is police review at the state or federal level, which could easily minimize these problems.

Re: Disturbing Police Strip Search Gone Bad

By luyen, February 8, 2008 at 14:44

I think in all fairness, these are (and i'm hoping anyway) exceptional cases rather than the general rule, i can only say that I feel terrible for that woman "Hope" - there are so many other ways to deal with this, why have to use force and traumatize this woman?

It's one step down from using a taser, but i'd argue it's probably even more traumatic being restrained and several people poking at our body parts -

Re: Disturbing Police Strip Search Gone Bad

By Heather Wallace, February 8, 2008 at 15:18

Yay! Lu's back in the house! I've missed your comments...

Re: Disturbing Police Strip Search Gone Bad

By Trisha Baptie, February 9, 2008 at 16:16

I just had to second Heather's Yay! I always enjoy reading your contributions!

Re: Disturbing Police Strip Search Gone Bad

By Roli Rivelino, February 7, 2008 at 01:03

Wow! It's footage like that that stops me wanting to go to America. It's frightening to think that a female middle class white victim of crime is treated like that; what chance would I have!?!

Re: Disturbing Police Strip Search Gone Bad

By Brandon, February 6, 2008 at 11:36

This story makes me sick to my stomach.
I hope she impoverishes every individual fascist involved; I hope they all go to jail for this battery; I hope once in jail these fascists are beaten and worse by inmates - and I hope when they die they go straight to hell.

Good on the news for playing this, probably despite some severe backlash from the popo - Lord knows, they stick together. They shoot people and electrocute people, beat, pepper-spray, assault, rape, and murder, and if anyone questions them they circle the wagons. Well, just like any organized violent gang really.

In any decent society these fascists would be forced to fall on their swords. Yeah that's right - If you're a cop involved in this or any incident like it you should kill yourself.

Re: Disturbing Police Strip Search Gone Bad

By Heather Wallace, February 6, 2008 at 13:58

Brandon - you took the words out of my mouth...except the part about the cops involved killing themselves. (Orato.com doesn't promote violence, self-imposed or otherwise.) But yes, someone should pay.

Re: Disturbing Police Strip Search Gone Bad

By Paul Sullivan, February 6, 2008 at 11:19

Michelle: Thanks for posting this video. Nothing, I repeat, nothing justifies the behavior of the police throughout this incident. Please keep Orato updated on the next chapters.

Paul Sullivan,
Editor-In-Chief